The Gospel According to Fishtown

There's a particular breed of neighborhood that emerges when history collides with hubris, when old-timers and art-school dropouts share the same sidewalk, eyeing each other like cowboys at high noon. Philadelphia's Fishtown is precisely that kind of glorious train wreck—except the trains are running on time, the wreckage has been repurposed into a cocktail bar, and someone's selling you a $14 pastry while explaining the Portuguese colonial spice trade.

I haven't been to Fishtown recently, but I don't need to stand there to tell you what it is. Some places you carry with you, lodged somewhere between your ribcage and your better judgment. Fishtown is one of those places—a neighborhood that's become a sort of secular pilgrimage site for anyone who believes that cities should be messy, delicious, and utterly unrepentant about their own transformation.

The Creation Myth

Let's start with the name, because of course we must. Fishtown wasn't christened by some branding consultant with a Pinterest board and a sociology degree. It got its name the old-fashioned way: people caught fish there. Specifically, shad from the Delaware River, back when the Delaware was something other than a scenic backdrop for luxury condos.

For two centuries, this was a working-class neighborhood in the truest sense—Polish and Irish and German and Ukrainian, an Eastern European sampler platter where the pierogi were serious and the bars never closed. Then, as happens in every American city with decent bones and relatively affordable rent, the artists showed up. Followed by the musicians. Followed by the people who make artisanal pickles. And suddenly, Fishtown wasn't just Fishtown anymore—it was Fishtown, italicized, hashtagged, profiled in glossy magazines as "Philly's Hottest Neighborhood."

Here's the thing, though: unlike so many neighborhoods that collapse under the weight of their own hype, Fishtown seems to have absorbed the transformation and come out the other side with its soul more or less intact.

Coffee as Social Architecture

The day in Fishtown begins not with prayer but with caffeine, which is its own form of worship. And if you want to understand the neighborhood's spiritual center, you start at La Colombe.

Calling this place a coffee shop is like calling the Grand Canyon a hole. This is a former industrial warehouse transformed into a cathedral of beans—soaring ceilings, exposed brick, enough natural light to perform surgery. On any given morning, it's packed with freelancers occupying every available outlet like squatters claiming homesteader rights, plus young parents maneuvering strollers with Formula One precision, plus the occasional person who appears to have wandered in accidentally and now can't figure out how to leave.

But more than excellent coffee, La Colombe functions as Fishtown's unofficial town square, the place where the neighborhood's many micro-communities briefly overlap. The tattoo artist ordering an oat milk cortado might be standing next to the architect ordering a pour-over, next to the retiree who remembers when this building made something other than caffeinated beverages.

If La Colombe is the cathedral, then Gilda is the neighborhood chapel—smaller, more intimate, and in possession of what might be the neighborhood's most dangerous morning pastry. This Portuguese market and café specializes in pastéis de nata, those impossibly delicate custard tarts that Portugal gave the world. These aren't just good; they're structurally perfect—crisp on the outside, wobbly on the inside, the kind of pastry that makes you understand why people used to go to war over spice routes. Pair that with their housemade linguiça breakfast sandwich and you've got the kind of breakfast that justifies waking up before noon.

For those seeking something historically rooted, there's Sulimay's Restaurant—old Philadelphia incarnate, with booths, linoleum, breakfast served all day, and a general sense that the world outside might be changing but the coffee here will remain exactly the same temperature it's been since 1979.

Where Fishtown Eats Its Feelings

If Fishtown has a competitive advantage in the urban neighborhood Olympics, it's food. The triumvirate that sits atop Fishtown's culinary pyramid represents three distinct corners of the globe, and together they've collected enough James Beard nominations to wallpaper a small apartment.

Suraya is the kind of restaurant that makes you understand why people throw around words like "transportive." This Lebanese restaurant creates an entire sensory experience—lush garden, natural light, the kind of design that looks effortless but absolutely isn't. Their baba ganoush isn't just smoky; it's the kind of smoky that makes you realize you've been eating inferior versions your entire life. The slow-roasted lamb is so tender it's practically philosophical.

Three blocks away, Kalaya is doing something similar but entirely different with Southern Thai cuisine. Chef Nok Suntaranon treats Thai food not as a simplified export but as a complex, sophisticated cuisine that deserves to be taken seriously. The menu is the opposite of the greatest-hits approach—this is miang pla phao (grilled branzino wrapped in herbs), tom yum kalaya (a towering bowl of hot-and-sour soup), regional Thai cooking that doesn't condescend or apologize for its intensity.

Rounding out the holy trinity is Laser Wolf, an Israeli grill from the duo behind Philadelphia's acclaimed Zahav. The meal begins with salatim—an endless parade of Israeli salads and sides. There's hummus whipped lighter than any hummus has a right to be. There's roasted eggplant, beets, probably a dozen other things that appear and disappear before you've properly registered them. Then, after you've already eaten what feels like a complete meal, the grilled meat arrives—smoky, charred, cooked over charcoal in a way that suggests open-flame grilling is the only legitimate way to cook anything.

We need to talk about pizza because Fishtown has a pizza situation. Pizzeria Beddia started as a tiny takeout shop making exactly 40 pizzas a night and became legendary for it. Now it's a sleek full-service restaurant serving world-class crisp pizza and natural wines. Down the street, Pizza Shackamaxon serves massive, thin-crust slices from a walk-up window—wide, floppy, heavily charred, and completely unpretentious.

Wm. Mulherin's Sons is housed in a restored 100-year-old whiskey facility, because of course it is. This is Fishtown in a nutshell: take historic architecture, add wood-fired Italian food and natural wines, and somehow make it all feel inevitable.

Worth a quick trip south to East Passyunk, El Chingon serves Mexican tortas and cemitas on house-baked sourdough, which is either brilliant fusion or terrible idea depending on your tolerance for culinary mashups. Spoiler: it's brilliant.

Where Fishtown Drinks

Frankford Hall is the neighborhood's German beer garden—a sprawling outdoor space where you can order liters of beer, play ping-pong, eat giant Bavarian pretzels, and pretend you're in Munich except everyone around you speaks English with Philadelphia accents. Other Half Brewing is for the beer nerds who understand what "DDH" means and have opinions about yeast strains.

For cocktails, R&D is where Fishtown goes when it wants to be sophisticated—dim lighting, knowledgeable bartenders, drinks that arrive looking like they've been photographed for a magazine. Then there's Murph's Bar, which is nominally a dive bar but secretly houses an incredible high-end Italian kitchen. Walk into what looks like a neighborhood watering hole and instead get housemade pasta that would hold its own against most proper Italian restaurants.

Johnny Brenda's deserves its own paragraph because it's the heart of Fishtown's cultural identity. Downstairs is a world-class gastropub. Upstairs is an iconic indie rock venue that's hosted everyone from The National to Father John Misty before they were famous. This is the kind of place that defines a neighborhood: unpretentious, excellent at multiple things, and completely unself-conscious about being excellent.

The Green Spaces and Cultural Touchstones

Penn Treaty Park is the neighborhood's front porch—10 acres of green space directly on the Delaware River with views that remind you Philadelphia is a waterfront city. This is where Fishtown comes to jog, walk dogs, have picnics, and stare at New Jersey while contemplating life choices.

More controversial and infinitely more photogenic is the Graffiti Pier, an abandoned industrial pier that's become an open-air art gallery. Technically, you're not supposed to be there. Realistically, everyone is there, especially at sunset when the light hits the layers of spray paint and everything looks like urban exploration poetry.

Harriet's Bookshop on Girard Avenue is proof that independent bookstores can still thrive if they're run by people who actually love books. Specializing in women authors and underrepresented voices, it's small but carefully curated, with staff recommendations that suggest the employees have actually read the books they're selling.

The Fishtown Paradox

Here's the uncomfortable truth: Fishtown is gentrified. Fully, completely, often expensively gentrified. The Portuguese families who've been here for generations remain, but they're surrounded by restaurants where entrees cost $38. The dive bars persist, but they're now considered "authentic" and written about in travel essays by people like me who don't live there.

This is the paradox of successful urban neighborhoods in contemporary America: the very things that make them interesting are inevitably transformed by their own success. But here's what's remarkable about Fishtown: it seems aware of this paradox and is actively wrestling with it. The old institutions remain protected and celebrated. The new restaurants employ locals and support neighborhood causes. There's a genuine attempt to maintain the community fabric even as the economic realities shift dramatically.

Why It Matters

Fishtown represents a version of urban America that actually works. This is a neighborhood that has absorbed massive change without collapsing into either sterile luxury development or nostalgic paralysis. It has world-class dining next to dive bars, craft breweries next to traditional bakeries. It's messy and contradictory and sometimes uncomfortable, which makes it human in ways that carefully planned developments never achieve.

So should you visit? If you care about food, if you're interested in urban neighborhoods, if you want to see what American cities can be when they embrace change without abandoning their past, then yes. Start at La Colombe with coffee. Walk to Penn Treaty Park and stare at the Delaware. Eat lunch at Suraya and dinner at Kalaya. Get drinks at Johnny Brenda's. Buy books at Harriet's. Eat too much pizza at Pizzeria Beddia.

And when you leave, you'll carry a piece of Fishtown with you—not in some mystical sense, but in the practical way that good neighborhoods imprint themselves on your understanding of what urban life can be. That's the gospel according to Fishtown: messy, delicious, and utterly unrepentant about its own transformation.

Just watch out for the scooters. They're everywhere, and they're piloted by people with varying levels of competence and regard for pedestrian safety. But that's cities for you—simultaneously brilliant and trying to run you over. Fishtown wouldn't have it any other way.

48 Hours in Portland

Where the Weird Stays Caffeinated Portland exists in defiance of easy categorization. It’s a city where tattooed baristas debate single-origin coffee with the intensity of sommeliers, where food carts have Michelin-level ambitions, and where the unofficial motto—“Keep Portland Weird”—isn’t just a bumper sticker but a civic responsibility. This

Stay48Jim Taylor

48 Hours in Eureka Springs

48 hours in Eureka Springs: Victorian architecture, Ozark trails, wood-fired pizza, live music, craft cocktails, and hillside streets that defy gravity.

Stay48Jim Taylor